The idea here is layers, so choose whatever sounds good to you. Chopped up water chestnuts are a nice addition. If I make this in a deep bowl, I make more dressing and make two sets of layers, with dressing in between the two sets.
Ingredients
Salad
1head lettuce
1pkg. frozen peas
1cupdiced celery
1/2cupchopped onion
1lb.sliced baconfried crisp and crumbled
1/4cupgreen peppersdiced
4hard-boiled eggschopped
1/4cupgrated Cheddar cheeseplus a little more for garnish
Dressing
1cupmayonnaise
2tblsp sugar
splash of lemon juice
Instructions
Tear lettuce and place in a large, see-through glass bowl.
Layer ingredients in order given.
Combine sugar and mayonnaise; spread mixture on top of salad.
Captain OCD used to run down to Fred’s and come back with potato salad that was a bit unusual in that it came from a store in a plastic container, but had lots of flavor and was delicious in a sturdy, potluck-picnic kind of way. Turns out that Diane, who worked there, made all the salads (her macaroni salad was also excellent), soups, baked beans, and most of the other typical deli-case dishes. While what you see in those glass cases in small, unfancy stores is usually mass-produced, bland crap, what resided in Fred’s case was a delightful surprise. I’m pretty sure she made them in her kitchen, which assuredly was not a certified kitchen, but no one cared: her stuff was good. Like all good cooks, she didn’t adhere to specific recipes, but she finally obliged Captain OCD and wrote down an approximation of her potato salad recipe. That’s below, exactly as she wrote it.
I found this recipe, scribbled on the back of part of a cigarette carton. A hastily scribbled favorite recipe on a torn-off part of a cigarette carton is a pretty good description of this potato salad. Bring this to your next picnic and, when someone condescendingly asks if that’s mayonnaise dressing those potatoes, say, no, it’s just a simple rustic emulsified vinaigrette.