Wash as many potatoes as you like, put them on a cookie sheet, and bake them at 400°. Small ones are best, but you can cut up larger potatoes and bake the pieces. Big russets are a little too tough for this process. How long you bake will depend on how big the potatoes are: at least 30 minutes.
Take the potatoes off the pan you just baked them on and drizzle lots of olive oil on the same pan. This helps the crisp factor, as well as preventing the potatoes from sticking to the pan.
Place the baked potatoes back on the olive-oil drizzled pan.
Smash the potatoes with a potato masher until they look like this. Drizzle plenty more olive oil over the potatoes. Sprinkle with salt, pepper, and herbs. You’re looking at kosher salt, chopped fresh rosemary, and smoked paprika. You’re not seeing black pepper because I don’t like it. Your guests can add as much pepper as they want when they eat them.
Bake at 450° for 25–35 minutes, until the potatoes are crisp around the edges. You’ve already baked them, so this step is just for the crispy party. The dark pieces on this pan are the cooked small bits of potato resulting from using the potato masher.
Serve the potatoes as is, or top with sour cream. Here, I added fresh chives because they were available in the chive pot outside.
Captain OCD used to run down to Fred’s and come back with potato salad that was a bit unusual in that it came from a store in a plastic container, but had lots of flavor and was delicious in a sturdy, potluck-picnic kind of way. Turns out that Diane, who worked there, made all the salads (her macaroni salad was also excellent), soups, baked beans, and most of the other typical deli-case dishes. While what you see in those glass cases in small, unfancy stores is usually mass-produced, bland crap, what resided in Fred’s case was a delightful surprise. I’m pretty sure she made them in her kitchen, which assuredly was not a certified kitchen, but no one cared: her stuff was good. Like all good cooks, she didn’t adhere to specific recipes, but she finally obliged Captain OCD and wrote down an approximation of her potato salad recipe. That’s below, exactly as she wrote it.
I found this recipe, scribbled on the back of part of a cigarette carton. A hastily scribbled favorite recipe on a torn-off part of a cigarette carton is a pretty good description of this potato salad. Bring this to your next picnic and, when someone condescendingly asks if that’s mayonnaise dressing those potatoes, say, no, it’s just a simple rustic emulsified vinaigrette.
Never again will I make mashed potatoes the day of a big dinner. With this recipe, I make them up to 2 days before, then just plug in the crock pot a few hours before dinner and get on with the rest of the cooking.
If you’re limiting your fat intake, I suggest not making these potatoes. To substitute low or nonfat ingredients would render this almost inedible.
Much like twice-baked potatoes. Frees up time and stove space on the day of a big dinner.
Course
Side Dish
Prep Time1hour
Cook Time3hours
Total Time4hours
Ingredients
5poundspotatoesyellow, and I usually throw in a few russets
1tablespoongarlicminced or roasted & smashed
8ozsour cream
8ozcream cheesesoftened
8ozcheddar cheeseshredded (or use a combination of whatever you like; I usually add Parmesan)
handful of green onionschopped fine
2cubes butteror more
half & halfas needed (I never need it)
salt to tastethat will be a fair amount
pepper to taste
Instructions
Cut potatoes into good-sized chunks. Don't peel yellow or red potatoes, but do peel russets.
Cook potatoes in salted water until done.
Drain and mash potatoes. It's okay to leave them a little chunky.
Add sour cream, cream cheese, and garlic.
Mash some more. If the mixture is too dry, add half & half until the consistency you like.
Fold in grated cheese and green onions.
Dump potato mixture into a well-buttered crock pot. If you're saving for another day, keep crock pot liner in refrigerator.
Take crock pot liner out of refrigerator about an hour before you plan to turn the crock pot on.
When ready to heat up again, place a kitchen towel (not a color that will leach into the potatoes) on top of the potatoes to absorb the condensation that will drip off the inside of the lid while heating in the crock pot.
Place the lid on top and turn on crock pot.
Cook on low for a few hours, stirring well every 30 minutes or so the potatoes don't brown against the sides and bottom of the crock pot.
The spicy comes from the hot peppers, should you choose to use them. I was told by tasters that the jars with the hot peppers were the best. For general canning directions, start here. Unless you really know what you’re doing, do not adjust the vinegar/water/sugar ratios in any pickled recipes if you’re going to can the results.
I don’t understand why, absent a gun to the head, anyone would choose to eat beets, so I’m no help in judging how these taste. Captain OCD grew beets for the first time this year and wanted old-school pickled beets with no fancy herbs or spices. He said these were exactly what he wanted.
* If you don’t know much about canning, you’ll find more specific (and official, so you don’t poison your family) canning directions here.